Shop by Sports Product
Shop By Trading Card Game
Visit Our Store
We're here to help you find exactly what you need. Stop by and experience our exceptional service.
Address
124 Granville St. Columbus, OH 43230
Phone
Email
Hours
Monday-Friday: 10:30 am-6:30 pm
Saturday: 12-5 pm
Sunday: Closed
Saturday: 12-5 pm
Sunday: Closed
Frequently asked questions
What is the return policy?
Returns are not accepted on products that are no longer factory sealed or factory wrap has been damaged. No returns unless item(s) do not match the description or photos. (LJ's Card Shop does not assume responsibility for consumer investment decision.)
*In such cases when there may be a legitimate issue with the item(s) that is grossly different from the description we are more than willing to discuss a return or refund.
What are you currently buying?
What we are currently buying will fluctuate throughout the year. Please see our "What We're Buying" Tab at the top of the page to see a quick list of what we are or are not buying.
What days do you buy/trade?
We buy on Monday, Wednesday, Friday and Saturday. If you have a large collection it is always best to call ahead to make sure we have time or to possibly make an appointment. We use Tuesday and Thursdays to process incoming cards/items.
How do you do payouts for trades?
We do payouts with Zelle, PayPal, Venmo or Cash. Cash is only available for payouts under $1000 in most cases. You may also choose store credit.
What percentage of market value do you pay?
There is not one percentage that will always apply across the board. There are many factors that may be taken into consideration. However, we do have a basic starting point.
For $10 and under we pay 50%
For $10-$19 we pay 60%
For $20 and up we pay 70%
For sealed product we pay 75% with some exceptions.
We will also make some exceptions on higher value, graded, or in demand items.
There are also cases where we would pay 75-80% on certain in demand cards.
How Do You Determine Value?
There are many factors we take into consideration.
- Current market trends
- Recent comparable sales of the same card on trusted online sources.
- Condition or Grade
- Market demand
- Current store inventory
Do you ship items?
Some items may be available for shipping. In that case, you will see an option pop up for shipping and it will be clearly noted in the listing. All other items are available for LOCAL PICKUP ONLY!